Res facta quae tamen fingi potuit (pauamma) wrote in suggestions,
Res facta quae tamen fingi potuit
pauamma
suggestions

Reverse-collapsed view of comment threads

Title
Reverse-collapsed view of comment threads

Short, concise description of the idea
Show (collapsed - timestamp, author, subject only) ancestor comments of the thread rooted in a specific comment, with that comment and the ones under it (up to a certain depth) being displayed expanded.

Full description of the idea
Currently, when you display a comment thread (like http://community.livejournal.com/efw/726978.html?thread=20996290#t20996290), the ancestors of the first comment of that thread aren't visible at all, and you need to follow the "Parent" link repeatedly (until you reach the toplevel comment that started the thread) to display them. In addition, when using that method, all "cousin" comments are also retrieved and displayed, which isn't always needed or desirable, if the goal is to reach quickly a comment somewhere upthread by a specific user, or with a specific subject. Having a 1-line-per-comment list of comments above the first expanded (fully displayed) comment would make that navigation task easier.

An ordered list of benefits
  • - easier upthread navigation
  • - (possibly) less load on servers, because the user doesn't have to retrieve the parent comments one by one, which currently also triggers retrieval and display of sibling/cousin comments not needed for the task at hand
An ordered list of problems/issues involved
  • - possible user confusion, because unlike the current view of collapsed threads, not all comments under a comment that's shown (expanded or collapsed) will be shown.
  • - (possibly) higher server load, because the ancestors of the first expanded comment (which aren't currently retrieved) may not be needed at all.
Tags: comment thread expansion, comment threading, comment viewing, comments, § no status
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 15 comments