finding my way (lyspeth) wrote in suggestions,
finding my way

Making the Suggestions page match reality a bit better

Making the Suggestions page match reality a bit better

Short, concise description of the idea
The /suggestions page is missing two things that I think would be helpful: a request to read the recent suggestions that haven't been put in the memories yet, and a note that it may take suggestions a while to be implemented.

Full description of the idea
Suggest to posters, via the Suggestions Area, that along with checking out the memories, they should check out recent posts. As to the other, there is a sentence on the page that says Don't let this deter you --- most ideas are good, and most are implemented very soon (often within a day or even an hour), but sometimes there are conditions which prevent certain features from being added immediately. This is misleading. While some suggestions are still implemented quickly (e.g. Yahoo status indicator) most are not, and it would be approrpriate to reflect this more accurately, but still encouragingly.

An ordered list of benefits

  • May reduce the number recent suggestions that are immediately re-suggested.
  • Will avoid frustration for those who would otherwise re-post recently-posted suggestions and get a "That was already suggested" response.
  • Will reduce frustration by not misleading people into thinking that most suggestions are implemented quickly.
  • An ordered list of problems/issues involved

  • People already don't seem to read the memories before suggesting, so adding something else for them to read might not help.
  • People might feel discouraged that most suggestions aren't implemented very quickly; an encouraging yet honest wording might be hard to work out.
  • An organized list, or a few short paragraphs detailing suggestions for implementation

  • Add a list item after "Check prior suggestions" reading "Read recent suggestions" with a link to the community's lastn page. Put a sentence after that says something like "This will help you avoid duplicating recent suggestions."
  • Change the wording of the sentence I cited above (and maybe the previous sentence, since devs aren't usually the ones explaining why it won't happen) to something like:
    After a suggestion is discussed for a while, it will be placed in the memories. From there, it may become an active project, or it may be postponed because of site conditions or time constraints. Don't let this deter you from suggesting things, however -- many suggestions are good and will improve the site when their time comes.
    (That's not the greatest wording, but you get the idea.)
  • Tags: ∞ suggestions admin: deprecated
    • Post a new comment


      Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

      default userpic

      Your reply will be screened

      Your IP address will be recorded